From Jerusalem to Los Angeles: Thuggery Rules

Israel bombs media offices, apartments in Gaza

Clash in Times Square. Fist fights broke out shortly afterward

Unlike my parents and grandparents, I never experienced much anti-Semitism in person. The one incident I can think of now is that in 1959, when I was applying to colleges, the guidance counselor told me not to bother with Cornell as they had a Jewish quota. But I’ve become aware, during at least the last two decades, of a rising tide of anti-Semitism in the U.S., conflated—oddly enough—on the left with anti-Zionism and on the right, under Trump, with pro-Zionism.

For the most part I stayed out of the crossfire. In 2002, however, Rainbow Grocery in San Francisco announced that it would boycott Israeli goods in protest against Israel’s oppression of Palestinians. I was no supporter of the Israeli government or its policies toward Palestinians, but I wrote to Rainbow Grocery asking if they would also stop selling Chinese goods to protest China’s treatment of Tibetans, or goods made in the U.S. to protest our government’s wide-ranging violent interference in other countries. I didn’t get an answer. Eventually, demonstrations by the Jewish community, a boycott of the store by customers, and a vote by coop members led management to scrap the Israeli boycott.

In 2014 Israel bombed Gaza. Jews in the town of Sderot, which had recently been hit by Hamas rockets, set old couches and lawn chairs on a hill and watched as though in a movie theater, eating popcorn and cheering at the explosions. I expressed my horror at this behavior to a nephew who is married to an Israeli. He replied that if he was there he’d do the same. “It’s a dog-eat-dog world,” he said.

Allan Sørensen, a Danish reporter, said this behavior was nothing new—he had seen the like when Israel was bombing Gaza in 2009. He had also seen Palestinians cheering the news of bombings that had killed Israelis. This is what happens in war, he said. People on both sides “go through a process of dehumanizing the enemy.” 

In 2017 the Chicago Dyke March banned a group of Jewish lesbians from carrying a rainbow flag with the six-pointed Star of David. The organizers said that the march was pro-Palestinian, and the Star was a symbol of Israel. The Star, in fact, has been a symbol of Judaism since at least the 14th century, long before the state of Israel existed. Two years after that march, when I attended the festivities celebrating the 50th anniversary of Stonewall, I brought armbands with a pink triangle and a yellow Star (sewn for me by a Christian fundamentalist friend) and several of us wore these armbands in the Reclaim Pride march.

Behind our Gay Liberation Front contingent, in the march, was another group chanting, “From the river to the sea, Palestine will be free.” I wondered whether they meant that Palestinians would be free of oppression and live alongside the Jews in peace, or that the State of Israel would be wiped off the face of the earth.

Anti-Semitic Hate Crimes—A Bigger Picture

Hate crimes against all minorities have been rising since 2014. Even before that, after 9/11 we saw a surge in hate crimes against Muslims. The election of Donald Trump brought about a significant upsurge in hate crimes in the United States. For example, after he called the current pandemic the “Chinese virus,” there has been a rash of violent attacks against anyone who looks Chinese. This rise in hate crimes includes right-wing anti-Semitic attacks. Anti-Semitism has also been increasing across Europe, both from neo-Nazis and pro-Palestinians.

I haven’t witnessed any of this personally, but attacks in the U.S. spiked during the recent bombing of Gaza. A reporter friend in NYC covered an assault on Jews who were eating at a restaurant in Manhattan and sent me a video. Readers may also have seen a video of the attacks on Jewish patrons of a sushi restaurant in Los Angeles, or read about similar thuggish behavior by both Jews and Arabs in Israel.

The Law of Return—Population Figures

An issue for both Jewish Israelis and Palestinians is the Israeli Law of Return, which gives Jews from any part of the world the right to enter the country and apply for citizenship. The law also applies to non-Jews with a Jewish background, or those living in a household with other Jews. Palestinians who left Israel or were driven out want that same right.

What if they all came? Let’s look at the numbers:

Population of Israel, Jews and non-Jews included                   9.2 million
Population of occupied West Bank                                          2.9 million
Population of the Gaza Strip                                                    1.8 million

Diaspora Jews and those non-Jews
who are eligible for citizenship                                   16.7 million
Diaspora Palestinians                                                                7.3 million

That’s 37,900,000 people to occupy a land of 8,778 square miles (m2)—which includes the West Bank, Golan Heights, and Gaza Strip. 172 m2 of the total is inland water, like the Sea of Galilee, and 4,633 m2 is desert. Although part of the desert is under cultivation, most is not. Water, both for household and agricultural use, is in limited supply. If all the world’s Jews and Palestinians arrived immediately, Israel would be the most densely populated nation on earth.

Realistically, though, 24 million people aren’t likely to immigrate any time soon. Most people who are reasonably comfortable where they live tend to stay there. That would include the majority of Jewish Americans. Poverty, oppression, and violence motivate those who do leave their homes.

From 2008 to 2018, the total number of Jews who moved to Israel was 252,507. How many Palestinians (and their descendants) would return if they could? Of those in Diaspora, over 1.5 million live in refugee camps, dependent on international aid for survival. Another 3.5 million are essentially stateless persons, living in various Arab countries without the right of citizenship, and sometimes being expelled or having to flee those countries because of conflicts, including the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait, the Gulf War, and the civil war in Syria. The remaining 2.3 million have made lives for themselves in countries that accepted them, mostly in Jordan, with around 400,000 scattered throughout the world. In other words, around 5 million would have a strong motivation to make use of the Law of Return if it applied to them.

In any case, even if nobody immigrates, and if Israel’s high birth rate remains the same, by 2065 that small country will become the second most crowded nation on earth.

Solutions?

Every pundit and politician knows how to settle the conflict. One columnist insists that the area should be divided into two states, and proposes borders according to some decades-old agreement. The next opines that the only workable solution is a single democratic state. Ultranationalists on both the Israeli and Palestinian sides have their answers as well—they each want to drive their opposite numbers out of the country entirely.

I don’t pretend to have a solution, and if I did, who would listen to me? I’m not optimistic. About 2,000 years ago, a Jewish preacher said, “Blessed are the peacemakers.” They may be blessed, but these days the thugs seem to be running the show.

4 Responses to From Jerusalem to Los Angeles: Thuggery Rules

  1. Mary Ann June 8, 2021 at 10:29 am #

    Thank you for this history lesson. I appreciate your wise perspective.

  2. Martha Shelley June 8, 2021 at 10:55 am #

    Thank you!

  3. Dajenya Shoshanna Kafele June 8, 2021 at 12:41 pm #

    Personally, I found “Witness in Palestine” by Anna Baltzer, (an American Jew), to be very illuminating. I also have read a few of Jimmy Carter’s books and others providing insights and education on the topic. While I understand the extreme anti-semitic oppression throughout Europe and genocide in Germany that led Jews to embrace the creation and defense of the state of Israel, the way it was created through the forced emigration of Palestinians and the aparteid conditions under which Palestinians live today tears at my heart, as a Jew, as much as it pained me each time my own government, the U.S., bombed other countries in my lifetime. Of course wrong has been and is being done on both sides, and peace-loving civilains on both sides suffer the atrocities their warring counterparts engender. But the numbers tell a lot about who has the power in this scenario and who is the most oppressed. While US news frequently mentions Israeli victims of Palestinian rockets, they rarely mention the approximately 10 Palestinians that die for every Israeli death. Only when hundreds or even thousands are massacred in a short period such as the thousands in 2014 or the hundreds in 2021, does the news speak of Palestinian “casualties.” Even now, some news outlets tell of the 13 Israelies killed by rocket fire without mentioning the 256 Palestinians killed by Israeli bombs. What is so illuminating about the book Baltzer wrote during her many months living in and traveling about the West Bank with various Palestinians who hosted her, is the close-up view of the conditions in the West Bank (not to mention Gaza) that explain why many today describe it accurately as an aparteid; conditions and restrictions on life that we, as Americans, could hardly fathom living in (and which propel anti-Israeli feelings among Palestinians). She also reveals clearly how the many folks she met were not anti-Jewish; they were anti-Israel because of what the state of Israel was doing to them. This very well documented and photo-illustrated journal of what Anna Baltzer saw and experienced in Palestine was quite eye-opening and I highly recommend it.

    • Martha Shelley June 8, 2021 at 3:09 pm #

      Some media have paid attention to Palestinian casualties, specifically the NY Times. My Zionist friends and relatives call the Times a “left wing rag.”

Leave a Reply

Privacy Policy

We do not retain any credit card information
and will not sell, lend, or otherwise transfer your
contact information to anyone, ever.